Primeˣ 260: Accuracy and Precision Assessment

Summary

The following report describes an accuracy validation test conducted with the Primeˣ 260 cameras. The test used a Thorlabs LTS-300C/M translation stage (<5um error) as a source of ground truth for the length of a 100mm translation, operationalizing the error of the camera system as offset from the values reported by the stage. An 8-camera Primeˣ 260 system exhibited a mean displacement error of 0.037mm (± .025mm) across nine 100mm translation trials, see Figure 3. Additionally, it demonstrated a static precision error of .015mm (± .009mm).

Methodology

Eight Primeˣ 260 cameras were mounted to truss, forming an 11m x 11m x 3.5m volume. The cameras were aimed toward a cart holding a Thorlabs LTS-300C/M stage in the center of the volume, see Figure 1. The Primeˣ 260 cameras were set to a gain of 2 and an exposure of 250us. Mounted to the stage were four 19mm AnchorPuck LEDs, which provided the positional data for the test. The camera-to-target distances ranged from 5.8m to 8.6m. The system was calibrated with a standard wanding procedure, achieving median wand and ray errors of .059mm and .237mm, respectively.

Figure 1: Left: The markers mounted to a linear stage. Right: A top-down view of the 3D volume.
Figure 1: Left: The markers mounted to a linear stage. Right: A top-down view of the 3D volume.

Results

Positional Accuracy

To evaluate the system’s positional accuracy, we compared the reported linear displacement of the markers (from their initial position) following a 100mm translation with the values reported by the Thorlabs LTS-300C/M linear stage. The results showed that the system exhibited a mean displacement error of <= 0.037mm (SD = .025mm) across four markers and nine trials, see Table 1 and Figure 2.

MeanSD95%
Translation Error (mm)0.0370.0250.083
Table 1: Accuracy Test Results

Static Precision

To test the system’s precision while stationary, the positional displacement of the markers from their initial position (average of first 15 frames) before the translation was calculated. Across the nine recordings, the average positional deviation was .015mm (SD = .009mm), see Table 2 and Figure 3.

MeanSD95%
Static Precision Error (mm)0.0150.0090.034
Table 2: Precision Test Results

Conclusion

In this test, a Thorlabs LTS-300C/M linear translation stage placed in the center of an 11m x 11m x 3.5m volume was used to validate the accuracy of our latest camera, the Primeˣ 260. The system of 8 Primeˣ 260 cameras reproduced the stage’s 100mm translations to within .037mm (± .025mm) across nine trials, demonstrating a static precision of .015mm (± .009mm).

Disclaimer

Achieving an optical tracking accuracy of <.1mm is not a simple task, even if the hardware is capable. Minute, nearly-imperceptible vibrations on only a few cameras can introduce additional noise and error into the system, especially as the distance between the cameras and the tracked object increase. Temperature changes can introduce additional noise at the interface between camera and mount, and within the truss system itself.

For these tests, numerous steps were taken to mitigate the influence of external noise: All degrees of freedom in the camera mounts were tightly secured with a wrench. The tests were conducted after-hours in an empty building with the HVAC system disabled. The cameras were calibrated at their operational temperature, with the accuracy and precision testing done immediately afterward.

Specifications and other information are subject to change without notice. All brand and product names are trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective holders. The information on this webpage is provided by the respective named manufacturer and is for general information purposes. These data constitute a concrete indication of properties and condition only if they are expressly indicated by EST or have been agreed upon as a condition in writing.

Scroll to Top
This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site. Switch to a production site key to remove this banner.